How Did We Scale Trust From Local Money Lending to Global Finance?
Written by Sanjivni Dwivedi
TL;DR
Scaling Trust in Finance through Institutions and Technology: The evolution of lending from local money lending to global financial systems has been driven by institutional frameworks and technological advancements, transforming how trust is built and maintained in financial transactions.
Key Innovations in Trust: Developments such as the credit scoring system, payment networks, and real-time processing have scaled trust beyond personal relationships, allowing financial systems to function efficiently across borders.
Persistent Challenges: Despite these advancements, financial exclusion, high transaction costs, and rigid credit assessments remain significant obstacles, particularly in developing regions.
Opportunities through Emerging Technologies: Blockchain technology and open banking offer new ways to improve transparency, automate processes, and expand access to credit, particularly for underserved populations.
The Future of Financial Trust: The balance between innovation and regulation will be crucial in maintaining trust as financial systems evolve. Ensuring fairness, transparency, and inclusivity will be key to making financial services accessible to all.
Imagine a world where lending money relied entirely on personal trust—like in The Godfather (1972), where Vito Corleone’s word was stronger than any contract. In those days, trust was built on face-to-face relationships, family ties, and community reputation. You knew the person you were lending to, and if they broke your trust, there were direct, sometimes severe, consequences. But today, things are different. We lend money across the world to people we’ve never met, trusting systems, institutions, and technologies to ensure that promises are kept.
What began as simple, personal transactions in close-knit communities has grown into a vast, complex financial system that spans the globe. This transformation didn’t happen overnight—it was driven by innovation in institutions and technology that allowed trust to scale beyond local interactions into the global financial markets we know today.
At the core of these changes is trust. What used to be a handshake between two people has evolved into a sophisticated network of legal frameworks and technological systems (Boot, 2000; Diamond, 1984). As financial systems expanded, so did the mechanisms to establish and maintain trust, growing from personal relationships to complex institutional frameworks. But how exactly did we get here, and what challenges lie ahead as we navigate this intricate global system?
To understand these, we need to look back at where it all began—when money lending was a local, personal affair, grounded in ancient practices. These early foundations laid the groundwork for the modern financial systems we see today, but new challenges emerge as we move forward, and these will be explored in the second half of this piece.
So, When Did We Start Lending Money and How Has It Evolved?
The history of lending can be traced back to ancient civilizations. In Mesopotamia, around 3000 BCE, temples acted as proto-banks, where trusted religious institutions managed transactions between individuals (Ferguson, 2008). The temples’ religious authority provided a strong foundation for trust, and their institutional permanence ensured that financial dealings would be honored. Similarly, in ancient Greece and Rome, personal trust networks underpinned informal lending systems, where familial and social relationships determined one’s access to credit (Ferguson, 2008; Graeber, 2011).
Formalizing this trust, the Code of Hammurabi (circa 1750 BCE) was one of the first legal frameworks to regulate lending practices. By establishing clear rules regarding interest rates and loan terms, the Code helped mitigate the risks involved in lending, ensuring that both parties were protected (Graeber, 2011). Royal courts also played a significant role in maintaining trust through legal oversight, especially as lending became more widespread across regions (Boot, 2000).
During the medieval period, private moneylenders began to dominate financial transactions, particularly in Europe. Trust in these moneylenders was built through personal relationships and local reputation. By the 12th century, banks managed by wealthy families, such as the Medicis in Italy, revolutionized lending. These banks expanded their operations by creating cross-regional networks, using reputation and trust within family ties to extend credit beyond local boundaries (Ferguson, 2008; Boot, 2000). The following table summarizes the discussed periods of lending with their trust mechanism and scale.
As these early banking networks laid the foundation for financial transactions across regions, the period from the 1500s to the 1900s brought about significant advancements, as banking institutions grew more formalized, structured, and capable of transforming the global financial landscape.
How Did Banking Institutions Evolve, and What Sparked Their Growth?
The Renaissance period brought significant advancements in financial systems, particularly through the rise of merchant banks in Italy. The Medici family, for instance, transitioned from merchants to international bankers, developing a branch banking system that allowed financial operations across borders (Ferguson, 2008). This model introduced formalized financial contracts, increasing the scale and scope of lending operations.
In the 17th and 18th centuries, joint-stock banks emerged, allowing for the pooling of capital and the distribution of risk among a larger group of shareholders (Neal, 1990). This development marked a crucial step in scaling trust, as investors were able to participate in lending activities without direct involvement in the operational risks of the bank itself. The concept of central banking began in the same period, with institutions such as the Bank of England (founded in 1694) playing a central role in maintaining financial stability by acting as lenders of last resort (Clapham, 2009).
These developments helped create a more stable and scalable system of financial trust. Central banks, by providing oversight and ensuring adequate reserves for private banks, mitigated the risks that had historically plagued financial markets, such as bank runs and liquidity crises (Diamond, 1984).
As financial systems continued to grow and evolve, the foundations laid by these early advancements paved the way for a truly global financial network. Yet, with this expansion came new challenges—how could trust be sustained at such a massive scale, across borders and through complex technological systems? This required the development of new mechanisms, designed specifically to scale trust in the modern era of finance.
How Are Trust-Scaling Mechanisms Shaping Modern Finance?
As global financial systems expanded, trust could no longer be sustained through personal relationships alone. The complexity of cross-border transactions and the scale of modern finance required new structures to ensure stability and security. To address these challenges, a variety of institutional mechanisms were put in place to safeguard trust and manage risk on a global scale.
Modern financial systems rely on a complex array of institutional frameworks designed to protect trust. These frameworks include:
Banking regulations: Government regulations, such as the Basel Accords, provide a standardized approach to risk management and capital adequacy, ensuring system-wide stability (Bank for International Settlements, 2021). Regulatory oversight also plays a crucial role in enforcing financial contracts and safeguarding consumer rights (Diamond, 1984).
Contract enforcement: The legal enforcement of financial contracts ensures that both lenders and borrowers are protected in the case of defaults or disputes. Well-established property rights systems also facilitate collateral-based lending, allowing banks to extend credit more confidently (Boot, 2000).
Property rights protection: Secure property rights allow lenders to reclaim assets in the case of default, reducing lending risk and promoting financial growth. The legal system's role in protecting these rights is crucial to scaling trust beyond personal relationships (Graeber, 2011).
While institutional frameworks provided the foundation for scaling trust, it was technological innovations that truly accelerated the speed, efficiency, and global reach of financial systems.
For instance, the introduction of the telegraph in the 19th century allowed for faster communication between banks, enabling quicker settlements and reducing transaction risks. By the 1960s, computers revolutionized data processing, allowing financial institutions to handle large-scale transactions with greater efficiency and accuracy (Ferguson, 2008).
The advent of the internet in the 1990s marked a turning point in global finance, enabling real-time transactions and the seamless transfer of funds across borders. This expanded the scope of financial trust from national to international markets (World Bank, 2022).
As technology advanced, it not only enhanced communication and transaction speed but also laid the foundation for systems that could standardize and quantify trust. These innovations allowed financial institutions to scale trust far beyond personal relationships and local communities, introducing more consistent and objective methods for assessing risk and making lending decisions.
One of the most transformative developments in this regard has been the Credit Scoring System. This standardized system allows lenders to evaluate a borrower's creditworthiness through data-driven methods, enabling more reliable and impartial lending decisions. Credit scores have become ubiquitous, offering a quantifiable measure of trust and extending it beyond personal networks, significantly reducing risk in financial transactions (World Bank, 2022).
In parallel, Payment Networks have also evolved. Real-time gross settlement (RTGS) systems and digital platforms like SWIFT have revolutionized cross-border transactions, facilitating instant payments and reducing delays. Digital wallets further expand the reach of financial trust, minimizing friction in international lending and ensuring secure, real-time transfers (Ferguson, 2008).
Building on the innovations in credit scoring and payment networks, technology continues to play a critical role in scaling trust in modern finance. The digital infrastructure that underpins today’s financial system allows real-time transaction processing, global settlement systems, and automated risk assessments to operate seamlessly. These technologies ensure that financial markets are not only efficient but also trustworthy at scale.
One key innovation is Digital Identity Verification, supported by cryptographic technologies, which has become essential in reducing fraud and securing personal data. As financial transactions increasingly occur across borders and without face-to-face interaction, the need to verify identities securely has never been more important (Boot, 2000).
Another powerful tool in trust scaling is Artificial Intelligence (AI). Advanced data analytics and AI are transforming the way financial institutions assess creditworthiness and detect fraud. By utilizing alternative data sources, such as social media behavior and transaction histories, AI models provide more accurate risk profiles. This not only improves traditional credit scoring but also broadens access to financial services, including borrowers who might have been excluded by conventional methods (Diamond, 1984).
Despite these technological advances, regulatory frameworks remain a crucial part of scaling trust in modern finance. The Basel Accords, for example, provide an international standard for assessing and managing risk. These regulations ensure that banks maintain sufficient capital reserves to withstand financial shocks, thereby safeguarding system stability (Bank for International Settlements, 2021).
While regulatory frameworks like the Basel Accords are essential for maintaining financial stability, they are only one piece of the puzzle. A robust network of institutions—central banks, commercial banks, credit rating agencies, and payment networks—works together to ensure the stability and liquidity of the financial system. These institutions facilitate cross-border transactions and provide the trust required for international finance (Ferguson, 2008).
While modern finance has successfully scaled trust through institutional frameworks and technological advancements, the system is far from perfect.
What Are the Persistent Challenges and Future Opportunities in Scaling Financial Trust?
Current Limitations:
Despite the significant progress in scaling trust, major gaps continue to hinder financial inclusion, particularly in developing regions. According to the World Bank’s 2021 Global Findex Database, nearly 1.4 billion adults remain unbanked, with most concentrated in low-income and developing countries (World Bank, 2022). A key barrier to inclusion is the high cost of financial services, exacerbated by rigid credit assessment criteria that rely heavily on formal income documentation and traditional credit histories. This excludes vast portions of the population who work in the informal economy, which accounts for over 85% of total employment in sub-Saharan Africa and about 60% in South Asia (International Labour Organization, 2021).
Operational inefficiencies also create hurdles, particularly in emerging markets. Lengthy documentation processes, bureaucratic delays, and high transaction costs contribute to the exclusion of small businesses and low-income individuals from formal financial systems. For example, transaction costs in sub-Saharan Africa can reach as high as 8.72% for remittances—more than double the global average of 4.93% (World Bank, 2021). These inefficiencies slow the adoption of financial services and impede the broader goal of financial inclusion.
Future Opportunities:
Emerging technologies present viable solutions to these persistent challenges. Blockchain technology, with its decentralized and immutable structure, offers a transparent, secure, and cost-effective way to manage financial transactions. Smart contracts, which execute agreements automatically when predefined conditions are met, could eliminate the need for intermediaries in lending, thereby reducing transaction costs and speeding up settlements. This is particularly relevant in regions where trust in financial institutions is low due to corruption or lack of transparency. For instance, the African Development Bank (AfDB) has explored blockchain solutions for enhancing transparency and improving credit access in countries like Kenya and Nigeria (AfDB, 2020).
Moreover, open banking initiatives are revolutionizing how credit is assessed. By allowing third-party financial service providers to access consumer banking information via secure APIs, open banking can incorporate alternative data sources, such as utility bills or mobile phone usage, into credit scoring models. This could significantly expand access to credit for populations typically excluded from the formal financial system. In the United Kingdom, where open banking has been implemented since 2018, over 4.5 million consumers and businesses are now using open banking-enabled services (Open Banking Implementation Entity, 2022).
What’s Next?
The journey from local moneylenders to a complex global financial system is a testament to humanity's ability to scale trust across borders, cultures, and technologies. Institutional frameworks, regulatory oversight, and groundbreaking innovations such as credit scoring and payment networks have all contributed to this remarkable transformation. Yet, as we celebrate these achievements, it is crucial to recognize the persistent gaps that still prevent millions from accessing essential financial services. Financial exclusion, operational inefficiencies, and the rigidity of traditional systems continue to limit the potential of many, particularly in developing regions.
Emerging technologies, such as blockchain and open banking, offer new pathways to address these challenges. By decentralizing trust and expanding access to credit through alternative data, these innovations promise a more inclusive financial future. But as we embrace this next wave of technological advancement, important questions remain: How do we ensure that innovation does not outpace regulation, leading to new risks and vulnerabilities? Can trust in decentralized systems truly replace the confidence that centralized institutions have built over centuries? And most critically, how can we strike a balance between advancing technology and ensuring that financial services remain accessible and fair to everyone, especially the most vulnerable?
As the financial landscape continues to evolve, the responsibility lies with governments, regulators, and innovators alike to safeguard trust as the cornerstone of global finance. Without trust, the most advanced systems will fail to serve the people they were designed for. As we look to the future, we must ask ourselves: Can we build a financial system where trust is not only scaled but also deeply rooted in fairness, transparency, and inclusion?
References:
African Development Bank (AfDB). (2020). Blockchain technology: Enhancing transparency and improving credit access in Africa. https://www.afdb.org
Bank for International Settlements. (2021). Basel III: International regulatory framework for banks. https://www.bis.org
Boot, A. W. A. (2000). Relationship banking: What do we know? Journal of Financial Intermediation, 9(1), 7-25. https://doi.org/10.1006/jfin.2000.0282
Clapham, J. (2009). The Bank of England: A history (Vol. 1). Cambridge University Press.
Diamond, D. W. (1984). Financial intermediation and delegated monitoring. The Review of Economic Studies, 51(3), 393-414. https://doi.org/10.2307/2297430
Ferguson, N. (2008). The ascent of money: A financial history of the world. Penguin Books.
Graeber, D. (2011). Debt: The first 5000 years. Melville House.
International Labour Organization. (2021). World employment and social outlook: Trends 2021. https://www.ilo.org
Neal, L. (1990). The rise of financial capitalism: International capital markets in the age of reason. Cambridge University Press.
Open Banking Implementation Entity. (2022). Open banking: Customer usage statistics. https://www.openbanking.org.uk
World Bank. (2021). Remittance prices worldwide. https://remittanceprices.worldbank.org
World Bank. (2022). Global financial development report 2021: Financial inclusion and development. https://www.worldbank.org
All artworks are designed by Yosha Waghela
If you enjoyed reading this blog and would like to receive more such articles from Scaling Trust, please subscribe our blog using the below link:
Alternatively, know more about us on our website here.
Keep in touch with us on: Linkedin | X | Telegram | Youtube | Email